Skip to main content

Art for art’s sake?

Art for art’s sake?

Picture This… March 2020

The monthly ‘Picture This…’ articles highlight items from the collections of Canterbury Cathedral Archives and Library and related collections, and are written by postgraduate students from the University of Kent and Canterbury Christ Church University, staff from the three institutions and guest contributors. The year 2020 is an anniversary year of St Thomas Becket, and throughout the year ‘Picture This…’ will focus on Becket.

Author: Dr Paul Dryburgh, Principal Records Specialist (Medieval Records) at The National Archives (UK)

TNA E 36/274, folio 295 (recto)

The cult of the martyred St Thomas Becket took many forms across medieval Europe. The saint’s image proliferated and was reshaped by its application in new contexts: in wall paintings, stained glass, pilgrim badges, illuminated manuscripts and also on seals, as Professor Anne Duggan splendidly demonstrated in her December post for this blog on the counterseal of Archbishop Stephen Langton. Artistic representations of Becket in archival collections are not limited to these formats, though. Tucked away in what is known as ‘Liber A’ in the archive of the medieval Exchequer – the financial arm of royal government – is this rather grisly doodle depicting the martyrdom. As the sword pierces the skull of the tonsured, bearded and robed archbishop, the mitre is toppled from his head, though the saint holds his hands forward in blessing, an image reminiscent of the scene depicted on Langton’s counterseal.

 

The doodle is found in one of the most important works compiled and retained for permanent reference by the Treasury of Receipt in the Exchequer, the repository for royal valuables and records housed, mainly, in the Chapel of the Pyx and the Chapter House of Westminster Abbey.

 

TNA E 36/274, folio 17 (recto) – warrior bearing a lance with banner, signifying the section dealing with the marriage of Alphonso, heir to the kingdom of Aragon, and Eleanor, daughter of Edward I

It is essentially a pictogram, an aide-memoire and visual point of reference for the Exchequer clerks in a volume compiled for King Edward I (ruled 1272-1307) between c.1282 and c.1292. (Liber B contains transcripts of records from c.1292 to c.1305.) It is one of several such pictograms that give readers a clue to the contents of the varied sections of the book. The doodle is not particularly unusual either; throughout the corpus of English medieval records we find numerous examples of heads, mythical beasts, hands and crude sketches that act in some way as references for the clerks who managed the information contained within them.

 

Sections of Liber A include papal bulls, letters, treaties and other muniments relating to England’s relationship with Scotland, Wales and Ireland and to royal marriages (including the doomed betrothal of Edward of Caernarfon, the young heir to the English throne, and Margaret, the ‘Maid of Norway’, heir to the throne of Scotland who died on voyage to her kingdom in 1290). It also contains transcripts of statutes of the realm and documents relating to ecclesiastical privileges and the relationship between Church and State.

 

TNA E 36/274, folio 299 (recto) – the baiting of Bosse the bear

The Becket doodle is found at the head of a two-folio (ff. 296r-297v) transcript of the proceedings of John Peckham, Archbishop of Canterbury, in a provincial council of bishops held at Reading in June 1279. Peckham was a Franciscan friar who had built up a powerful intellectual reputation studying and teaching at the universities of Paris and Oxford. His appointment as Archbishop of Canterbury in January 1279 brought him into closer contact with secular administration and also emboldened him to continue and enhance the legislation of earlier in the century that aimed to ensure the Church had the human resources and the licence to minister effectively throughout the nation.

The transcript in Liber A lists the ‘constitutions’ promulgated at Reading. These regulated such life events as baptism and concubinage (co-habiting of men and women who are not legally married). Peckham further aimed to tackle the issue of institution to church offices and pluralism, the possession of multiple benefices by clerks and their non-residence in their parishes.

TNA E 36/274, folio 40 (recto) – image of the pope and a papal bull

Some bishops and many royal clerks were instituted to several offices and did not look kindly on the statutes, and the government used pluralism as a way of rewarding its personnel. By the end of 1279 Peckham had excommunicated anyone resisting the Reading statutes. Parliamentary opposition forced Peckham to back down to some degree and agree that none of the statutes would prejudice the king or his kingdom.

Medieval government clerks are known for their sense of humour, which is best revealed through their doodling. Here in this tiny doodle, no more than a couple of centimetres in height and width, we have a conundrum. Yes, the drawing is clearly that of Thomas Becket. But are the Exchequer clerks using the powerful image of his martyrdom to remind themselves of the enduring clerical struggle against secular power, or is the artist perhaps cocking a snook at his legacy so recently encapsulated in the activities of John Peckham, whose death in 1292 coincided with the possible end date for the compilation of the volume?

TNA E 36/274, folio 287 (recto) – the mitred head of St Swithun in a section concerning the election of the prior of St Swithun’s Winchester

Further Reading:

A.H. Hershey, Drawings and sketches in the Plea Rolls of the English royal courts c.1200-1300 (Kew: List & Index Society Special Series 31, 2002).

Benjamin Thompson, ‘The academic and active vocations in the medieval church: Archbishop John Pecham’, in The church and learning in later medieval society: essays in honour of R.B. Dobson: proceedings of the 1999 Harlaxton Symposium. ed. C. M. Barron & J. Stratford (Harlaxton Medieval Studies, 11: Donington: 2002), pp. 1-24.

M. C. Prestwich, Edward I (Newhaven & London, 1997).

M. Morris, A Great and Terrible King: Edward I and the forging of Britain (London, 2008).

Back to top of page